Heirloom facepalm 05/11/2016 07:33 PM CDT
61 SEARCHES to find my heirloom tonight. I did room orders like A B C and finally A B C D (so I never searched the same two rooms in a row). I also died twice.

Could we get a hard cap on the number of searches and the number of loots for heirlooms, please?

If you really want the logs....I do have them.
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/14/2016 12:23 PM CDT
Ugh seriously.

Just searched 58 times and gave up.

Can we not search rooms in the order of A B C A B C to find an heirloom? This was stated by a GM as an acceptable method a couple years ago, maybe I can dig up the post.

Or am I just getting bad luck?

This is driving me insane. It's like 20 to 25 minutes empty-handed kneeling. There needs to be a ceiling on this.
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/14/2016 03:29 PM CDT
<Can we not search rooms in the order of A B C A B C to find an heirloom? This was stated by a GM as an acceptable method a couple years ago, maybe I can dig up the post.>

Been awhile since I got assigned this but even A B B A should work.

<Or am I just getting bad luck?>

Sounds like.

<There needs to be a ceiling on this.>

Yea, 58 is nuts.
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/14/2016 04:18 PM CDT


One thing to make surezis that the location is correct. Sometimes its easy to catch a room that wont count.
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/14/2016 04:28 PM CDT
I was under the impression you needed to go through at least 4 rooms for the best chances.

Assuming that there's a 10% chance to find the heirloom, you should have a 99.75% chance to find the heirloom in 57 searches. If it's 15% (which has been my impression, but I've never kept stats), that goes up to 99.99%.

So either there's a new bug or you're doing something wrong. I heard the 4 room advice somewhere, so I'd assume it's the latter.
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/14/2016 04:35 PM CDT
>Can we not search rooms in the order of A B C A B C to find an heirloom? This was stated by a GM as an acceptable method a couple years ago, maybe I can dig up the post.>

>Been awhile since I got assigned this but even A B B A should work.

Neither of those will be particularly helpful to your chances of finding a heirloom. Searching the same 2-3 rooms over and over is not (nor has ever been) a successful heirloom search strategy. Search as many -different- rooms within the given search area as possible.

Coase
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/15/2016 06:58 AM CDT
>Searching the same 2-3 rooms over and over is not (nor has ever been) a successful heirloom search strategy. Search as many -different- rooms within the given search area as possible.

Thanks Coase! I guess I'm more likely to go crazy eating the bullet several times rather than how many attempts it takes for the next one.

:D
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/15/2016 07:42 AM CDT
>Can we not search rooms in the order of A B C A B C to find an heirloom? This was stated by a GM as an acceptable method a couple years ago, maybe I can dig up the post.

Vanah said back to back searches don't count, which is not the same thing as saying ABCABC is giving full value. (Post 985 above)
Reply
Re: Heirloom facepalm 05/29/2016 03:17 PM CDT
Just popping back to say thanks again for the advice. My heirloom searching is going much better now!
Reply