I am happy to report that this is the case. <beam>

So there I was, walking back from the bank to a resting spot... when whom do I see just standing on the street by Syllanus. <blink> Spawn up a Yahoo! email page to check... yep. That's the name, alright.

Logoff that character, go whistle up Krakii, and wander over to where he is.

.

Believe it or not, folks, on the say-so of this crazy wild-eyed Dwarf accosting him on the street and babbling about some years-old email (looks like I sent it to him on 14 August of 2006), he checks his locker and sure enough, there's the item she's on about.

Just on that basis, he goes to his locker and gets it, returning "an enruned rolaren spear" (from one of the late-90s Auctions here on the web, self-mana [single, not double] Foraging).
(Foraging got a lot more attractive after Alchemy, and then the Adventurer's Guild, came out. Hence my email of then, trying to reclaim the spear.)

.

.

Way to go, Syllanus. And welcome back!