Trying to get a favor orb from Eylhaar in the Eyes of the Thirteen (Crossing Temple).
I have a jackal pelt for a sacrifice but can't figure out how to offer it. Wondering if it's because the pelt isn't fresh or if it's the wrong sacrifice altogether. I have the correct altar. It doesn't need cleaning. I have the pelt in my right hand.
This is the messaging I get when I try to offer the pelt regardless of how general or specific I am:
You must specify what you are offering.
Usage: OFFER (offering) on (altar)