Smoked Ribs Help Request 04/11/2008 12:12 PM CDT
I know we have some food connoisseurs in DR, I'm hoping one will be a smoked rib specialist.

I recently got a smoker, an inexpensive electric smoker, which I know is not authentic or best, but its easy for a first time user. I'm trying to make some dry smoked ribs. The smoke smells right, but it isn't permeating the meat. Its only been about 3 hours, so I am pretty sure I am going to have to leave them on for 6+ more, but I want to make sure I am not forgetting anything else.

I rubbed them before I put them on with splenda, salt, chili powder, garlic, and onion.

The ribs have a hint of the taste I am looking for, but it really isn't strong enough. Is time the only answer? What else should I be doing? Any hints, tips or tricks would be nice.

I'm not a big fan of slathering them in BBQ sauce to increase flavor, I want BBQ to accent the taste, not mask it.

Thanks!
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request 04/11/2008 12:23 PM CDT
<<I rubbed them before I put them on with splenda, salt, chili powder, garlic, and onion.>>

when cooking, use the real stuff. real sugar, salt, butter, ect. I know people try and live healthy and cut back on a few things, but seasoning doesn't contribute much in the way of calories and such. Bland food is just, blechhh. Low quality ingredients will never lead to high quality dishes.

I can't help much with ribs, never cooked them in my restaurant career

Yamcer


"You know, while I understand the importance of seeing the (personal) validity in other's arguments, it's impossible for me to believe fully that others are correct. If their argument was correct, I'd change mine." - My GF
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request 04/11/2008 01:34 PM CDT
Yeah, in retrospect, I figure I shouldn't have substituted anything at all when first learning. Splenda is just so close, I figured I would give it a shot.

I figured out a few of my mistakes and have fixed them. Most importantly, after a few hours the hickory doesn't smoke as much and you have to add more. I'm going to see how this batch does and then try a more complex rub.

Any other ideas or hints would be very helpful.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request 04/11/2008 07:14 PM CDT
High quality food satisfies better.

You don't end up with people filling in the holes and trying to feel satisfied by consuming junk if they have had a good high quality meal that satisfied them.

In the end you are better off with the real stuff prepared right.


"No one can make you feel inferior without your consent."
--Eleanor Roosevelt
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request 04/12/2008 02:12 AM CDT
Rules for Smoking Success.

1. LOW & SLOW .... by allowing the meat to cook at low heat and longer periods then allowing the meat to sit and cool after its cooked for at least 30 mins will ensure moist and tender meat.

2. Find yourself a good rub recipe. DO NOT FOR ANY CIRCUMSTANCE USE SUBSTITUTE/ARTIFICIAL INGREDIENTS.
(Alternatively how on earth did you make a rub without brown sugar. for shame!)

3. Quality meat = Quality Meal

4. Use good wood. I like Hickory & apple wood are my favs. Ive seen folks soak thier woods along with charcoal to give it that charcoal taste (Paula Dean did this recently on one of her shows)

5. Dont peak. Peaking lets out precious smoke/flavor and heat. If you fear your meat is drying out use a spray bottle filled with apple juice & water to spritz the meat.

If you want a good rub recipe that will also give you a basis for tweaking it to your tastes I suggest you search Food Network.com for Alton's Brown's Rib Rub. (My own rub is based off his measurements)
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request 04/13/2008 08:41 AM CDT
My second batch was a lot better, I used brown sugar, garlic, onion powder, ground red pepper, and mustard seed. I let it sit in the fridge for about 2 hours and then smoked it for three.

I have a shopping list now for rubs I am going to try, including Alton's rub you mentioned.

Thanks for the help!
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/13/2008 03:05 PM CDT
here is the recipe for the seasoning i use on everything. was called Fry Salt at the restaurant i stole it from. We used it on the prime rib, in the tuna melt, on burgers, fries, fish, pretty much everywhere.

The original recipe i got was to make 5 gallons of the stuff, so i've lowered the amount to fill a large coffee can size container

AmountIngred.
1/2 cup Sugar
2 cupKosher salt (large rock salt)
1 cupLawry's seasoned salt
1 cupOnion salt
2 cupGarlic powder
1 cupBlack pepper (fine ground)


for our prime rib we'd put 2 Tbs worchester's sauce, 2 Tbs Fry salt (see above), 2 Tbs dried Oregano, 2 Tbs dried Parsley.

With seasoning, i always liked to use Kosher salt since the large granules don't fully dissolve into the dish and give your pallet flavor boosts. I save the fine ground stuff for baking pretty much.

Cooking is fun, experiment, enjoy.

Yamcer


"You know, while I understand the importance of seeing the (personal) validity in other's arguments, it's impossible for me to believe fully that others are correct. If their argument was correct, I'd change mine." - My GF
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/14/2008 10:31 AM CDT
Smoking food itself is an art form. Takes a long time to master. I have had my share of big time screw ups. Not so bad screwing up ribs, but I have screwed up close to 200lbs of salmon over the coars of the years.

When smoking food, make sure your wood is thoroughly soaked. Your wood will work better when it is more wet, I usually soak my wood over night before a smoke day. I prefer cherry wood, but I have used pear, apple, hickory, almond and walnut. For all around flavor almond is probably the best. It is a very versatile wood that doesn't drown out the other flavors with smoke as much as hickory does.

One thing you can do, is cook the ribs from a half hour to about an hour and a half depending on the type of grill before you smoke, it will cut down the smoking time in half. Ribs themselves on pure smoke take about 8 to 10 hours or more to do them right which makes it take forever. I generally on smoke alone will cook my ribs about 12 hours. I start around 4 or 5 am to have them ready for dinner time.

If you smoke you really don't need much rest time since the heat is low. If you BBQ food or bake or whatever give all your meat about 30 minute covered rest time before slicing and serving also remember even when you pull it out of the oven or off the grill it will continue to cook for a while and the temperature will rise in the center.


Arctuniol

Knowledge is like manure, it's only good when spread.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/14/2008 11:58 AM CDT
This may sound silly, but do specific woods lend flavors similar to the fruit they bear?

For example, does pear make food taste a bit like a pear?

Also, I have heard soaking your food in different liquids make it taste better. I don't necessarily want my foods tasting like apples though, should I use apple juice. I don't want to overpower the smoke taste with fruitiness.

I'm going to order some woods online and give them a shot.

Thanks for everything! I have a slab sitting in the fridge now with Alton's rub on it, and one with a Memphis style rub on it. YUM!
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/14/2008 12:53 PM CDT
Here's a great site for you to check out

http://www.bbqu.net/
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/15/2008 11:24 AM CDT
Specific woods do lend specific flavors, my brother prefers local apple wood.

mfberg
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/15/2008 11:58 AM CDT
Yes, also, if you are cooking for other people, some people are allergic to specific woods.


"No one can make you feel inferior without your consent."
--Eleanor Roosevelt
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/15/2008 10:34 PM CDT
If they are allergic they should make it known. I personally don't provide menus or choices when I cook, or take requests for meat or non-meat. food gets cooked, stuff is put on the table. Everything is always eat at your own risk. Works better that way. Now if I was cooking in a restaraunt that would be different.


Arctuniol

Knowledge is like manure, it's only good when spread.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 12:05 PM CDT
Being someone who's allergic to approximately everything, I make it my responsibility to check with friends that are cooking for me as to their ingredients. I know that it's me who could have the very expensive ER visit, and I don't ask 20 people to remember that seafood kills me. In return, they don't get offended if I bring something else to eat instead.


Meli
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 12:13 PM CDT
I have to watch allergies too, and I agree, it's the responsibility of the allergic person to check.

What I hate is when I do check and the person who made the food is not on the up and up. I have some relatives that think it's acceptable to do this to protect their 'secret recipies'. Needless to say I simply don't eat what they make and as far as I'm concerned the offense they then take is their problem not mine.


"No one can make you feel inferior without your consent."
--Eleanor Roosevelt
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 12:15 PM CDT
>>What I hate is when I do check and the person who made the food is not on the up and up. I have some relatives that think it's acceptable to do this to protect their 'secret recipies'. Needless to say I simply don't eat what they make and as far as I'm concerned the offense they then take is their problem not mine.


I know a guy that's deathly allergic to onions. Sometimes when he goes to a fast food place he'll ask for no onions and they'll say something stupid like "They're chopped real small, you won't notice them" or they'll just put them on anyway. Some people are inconsiderate
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 01:01 PM CDT
>I know a guy that's deathly allergic to onions. Sometimes when he goes to a fast food place he'll ask for no onions and they'll say something stupid like "They're chopped real small, you won't notice them" or they'll just put them on anyway. Some people are inconsiderate

Yeah, some people just don't understand allergies. My cousin is allergic to a few things, including dairy. He regularly gets cheese on things even after he asks for no cheese. He's sent burgers back only to have them returned with the cheese scraped off.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 03:26 PM CDT
>>With seasoning, i always liked to use Kosher salt since the large granules don't fully dissolve into the dish and give your pallet flavor boosts.

It also contains about 20% less sodium per serving compared to table salt. Good stuff.

>>Yeah, some people just don't understand allergies. My cousin is allergic to a few things, including dairy. He regularly gets cheese on things even after he asks for no cheese. He's sent burgers back only to have them returned with the cheese scraped off.

I don't have any food allergies, but some of my friends do, and my girlfriend doesn't eat land meat as I call it, so I totally understand and it frustrates the heck out of me. It's sloppy and inconsiderate, and if the allergy is made known, it can lead to legal repercussions as well.

>>apple juice and ribs

You can also try a solution of apple vinegar and water. When I went to (east) NC, the SOP was to apply vinegar to the meat toward the end of smoking. Specifically, I got times from 30 minutes before taking it off the grill to doing it when you pull the pork, according to several restaurants and diners at which I feasted on their delicious smoky pork bbq. As when marinating, vinegar helps to tenderize the meat and it adds a great tang.

Also, I agree on using real ingredients in rubs. I wouldn't even use store-bought chili powder--I would make my own. Why? Most chili powders contain preservatives and often glutemates to enhance flavor (e.g. MSG), which I'm sure you know some people are allergic to. Really, it's just...not authentic and not necessary. Vinegar combined with good cuts of meat will give all the umami of MSG when used appropriately, if that's what you're looking for.

Good luck with your new smoker! I can't wait to do some beef barbeque myself this summer, so do be sure to share your results!

Buon appetito,

~Mike/player of Gulphphunger
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 03:28 PM CDT
>>I went to (east) NC, the SOP was to apply vinegar to the meat toward the end of smoking.

Sphere of Protection exists in real life?

::ducks and runs::
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 05:00 PM CDT
Keep in mind that they might not actually know they are allergic. Particularly with shellfish and nut allergies, it can "spontaneously" start up and become fatal in the very first attack. These allergy deaths appear to be increasing in number, by the way, so you might need to start keeping an eye out if you have a lot of new faces coming around.

J'Lo, I'm a ranger.. I'd believe anything.....
The Manipulation List -- http://symphaena.com/index.html
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 05:50 PM CDT
>>Keep in mind that they might not actually know they are allergic. Particularly with shellfish and nut allergies, it can "spontaneously" start up and become fatal in the very first attack. These allergy deaths appear to be increasing in number, by the way, so you might need to start keeping an eye out if you have a lot of new faces coming around.


As someone who's allergic to shellfish I can't tell you how lucky I was that someone had an Epi-pen when I first found out

Denz


If you want to be okay with a weapon and use a bunch of magic too, be a Warrior Mage. If you want to own the world with your you weapon and take a good deal of what the world throws at you while laughing in the face of magic, be a Barbarian.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 08:22 PM CDT
Well, I did something wrong with the beef ribs, because they don't taste right. They smelled great, but didn't take on any smoky flavor.

Is it possible to put too much rub on the meat so the smoke doesn't get through? Here was the rub I used

dry rub:

One quarter cup dark brown sugar
Three tablespoons paprika
Two tablespoons ground black pepper
One tablespoon celery salt
One tablespoon onion powder
Two teaspoons garlic powder
Two teaspoons mustard powder
One teaspoon ground cumin
One half teaspoon ground cayenne
One half teaspoon chili powder
Two teaspoon mustard seed

pat ribs with 1 tablespoon Worcestershire, 1 teaspoon molasses, 1 teaspoon honey.

I am going to try another set of pork ribs try it on those before I try beef again. Any hints or observations are always appreciated.

As for allergies, I am no where near sharing my BBQ with anyone else. Once I get some good BBQ skills, I'll see about sharing.

Thanks all!
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/16/2008 10:15 PM CDT
Probably just didn't smoke it enough, or use enough wood. You need to make sure it is really really smokey. You can't just put one piece of wood and expect it to take. Put in a handful, make sure it smokes out your entire household and the three or four houses to each side, or apartment buildings. Either way use a lot of wood, and try to limit the smoke loss as much as possible. I think one of the best smokers around, are the ceramic eggs. I so want one.


Arctuniol

Knowledge is like manure, it's only good when spread.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 09:07 AM CDT
normally when i smoke i wrap the wood chips in foil and poke some holes. Dont know how the pros feel about that, but it works great for me.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 09:14 AM CDT
It is a good idea to do that when you are using a gas grill. I have never done it using a wood/charcoal grill.


Arctuniol

Knowledge is like manure, it's only good when spread.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 09:44 AM CDT
You have to put new chips/chunks in every hour too
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 09:49 AM CDT
>>You have to put new chips/chunks in every hour too

Hmm, that could be difficult. The way my smoker is set up there are two racks of food right above the burner with the wood on it. I tried adding wood once, lit my hot pad on fire, decided better not do that.

I was lucky that I didn't touch any sides and burn my arms.

I think I can find some long silicone gloves or something like that at a local kitchen store that might work.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 09:52 AM CDT
Try Tongs?
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 10:16 AM CDT
Like Arct said you probably need more wood especially when cooking beef as it requires a bit more smoke to permeate the the tougher muscle fibers than compared to say pork ribs.

PS. If you're going to try pork stay away from baby backs (ie. ribs for folks on a diet as I call em) and get yourself a good slab of meaty St Louis ribs.

If you're going to try pork butt I'll give ya this tip.

Do not toss out the slightly charred ends. Put em on a cutting board get urself a cleaver and chop em up, toss em with a bit of franks hot sauce and some BBQ sauce and put it on a bun with some pickles and a side of slaw. Now thats some good eats

Denz


If you want to be okay with a weapon and use a bunch of magic too, be a Warrior Mage. If you want to own the world with your you weapon and take a good deal of what the world throws at you while laughing in the face of magic, be a Barbarian.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 11:43 AM CDT
>>Do not toss out the slightly charred ends. Put em on a cutting board get urself a cleaver and chop em up, toss em with a bit of franks hot sauce and some BBQ sauce and put it on a bun with some pickles and a side of slaw. Now thats some good eats<<

I ate a bit on accident the first time, decided they were the best part anyway. Very very tasty.


>>Try Tongs?<<

I only have a small metal plate that sits on the burner at the very bottom of my smoker, not box or anything that I could pull out, empty, fill, and put back.

I am using pretty small pieces of wood, I don't know that I could get a good hold of them with tongs and it would take a really long time to remove all the old wood and put new in that way.
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 12:00 PM CDT
http://www.bbqu.net/smoking4.html
Reply
Re: Smoked Ribs Help Request (fry salt) 04/17/2008 03:52 PM CDT
The burnt ends are totally the best part of the meat! My husband, who's from KC, introduced me to them. In fact, the one good KC-style place around here has both beef and pork as options for the main meat.

I totally want bbq tonight.

Meli
Reply